Best Pizza in Salt Lake City: 15 Must-Try Spots

BRUCE BIGFORD

Last Updated: February 15, 2026

Are you looking for the best pizza in Salt Lake City? The pizza landscape has evolved remarkably, offering a diverse array of styles and flavors that cater to every palate.

Fortunately, the city is now home to a premier selection of top pizzerias that offer exactly what you’re searching for—from traditional Neapolitan to innovative Detroit-style pies, here are the top 15 pizzerias you must visit.

1. Cosmica

Cosmica is famous for its wild-fermented sourdough pizza crust, bringing a tangy, artisan edge to traditional Neapolitan-style pizza. This unique combination recently earned them national recognition on The New York Times list of the best restaurants in America—a first for a Utah pizzeria in over a decade.

Chef Zachary Wade's creations, such as the clam pie, have been praised for their authenticity and flavor. Cosmica (full story) blends Southern Italian simplicity with a 1970s 'spaghetti western' vibe, featuring seasonal produce, leather booths, and a watchful portrait of Leo the dog. 

       945 S 300 W, Salt Lake City

📞  (385) 525-8600

 🌐 Website

2. Slice House by Tony Gemignani

World-renowned pizzaiolo Tony Gemignani brings his award-winning pizzas to Salt Lake City with Slice House (full story).  Offering New York, Sicilian, Grandma, and Detroit-style pizzas, the menu caters to diverse tastes by using premium ingredients and unique, varied crusts.

Designed as a fast-casual, neighborhood-focused concept, Slice House is the perfect spot for high-end to-go and delivery without sacrificing that artisan quality.

      1332 Foothill Dr, Salt Lake City

📞 (385) 464-5565

🌐 Website

3. Nomad East

If you’re looking for the "coolest" patio in the city paired with arguably the best crust in town, Nomad East (full story) is it. Taking over the charming space where Eggs in the City used to be, this spot has quickly become a Yalecrest favorite.

Everything here—from the roasted chicken to the peaches for dessert—is fired in their massive twin pizza ovens. Known for thin, crispy, and creative pies, Nomad East is where the locals go when they want something more elevated than a standard pepperoni.

Try the "Betty White" with garlic cream and pickled raisins or the "Roni-Boy" for a sweet-and-spicy kick.

      1675 E 1300 S, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 883-9791

🌐 Website

4. Slackwater Pizzeria

Slackwater Pizzeria (full story) pairs 20 artisan pizzas with a world-class selection of 300+ craft beers. Between the chill decor, live music, and friendly crew, it’s the ultimate neighborhood hangout.

Known for its inventive toppings, Slackwater's "California Sunrise" pizza has been recognized as Utah's best.  With a Green Goddess base, chicken, bacon, grape tomatoes, avocado, spinach, and a three-cheese blend, it's a must-try.

      684 S 500 W, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 386-9777

🌐 Website

5. Bricks Corner

Bricks Corner (full story) is Salt Lake City's award-winning Detroit-style pan pizza restaurant, serving up fresh, chef-driven pies in the heart of Sugarhouse since 2020. With multiple Best Pizza awards and a cult following across the valley, this is the pan pizza Salt Lake City has been waiting for.

Specializing in Detroit-style pizza, Bricks Corner offers crispy, caramelized cheese edges and fluffy dough. Their signature squares pair perfectly with local craft beers. Winner of City Weekly Best of Utah.

     1465 S 700 E, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 953-0636

🌐 Website

6. Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana

Authentic Neapolitan pizza baked in a 900-degree oven using San Marzano tomatoes and imported mozzarella di bufala.

Settebello offers a genuine Italian experience in downtown SLC. Established in 2005, Settebello was among the first U.S. pizzerias to recreate authentic Pizza Napoletana.

      260 S 200 W, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 322-3556

🌐 Website

7. Pizza Nono

A neighborhood gem serving wood-fired pizzas made from Utah-milled flour.  Specializing in pizza topped with arugula, spinach and other veggies, Pizza Nono is a favorite among locals.

Try the "Beehive" with hot honey and pickled jalapeños for a sweet and spicy kick.  Don't forget to try the tots and oven fired squash.

      925 E 900 S, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 702-3580

🌐 Website

8. The Pie Pizzeria – Underground

An SLC institution offering loaded, gooey, cheesy pies in a basement hangout near the University of Utah campus.  Pure nostalgia in every slice.

If you like lots of cheese then you are in the right place.  Lots of ingredients big crust and piles of melted cheese. Very good pizza.

      1320 E 200 S, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 582-5700

🌐 Website

9. Victor’s Pizza Co

Known for bold, experimental creations like the "Honey Bunny" featuring feta, salami, and hot honey, Victor's pizza always delivers.  

Victor's pizza boasts tasty cheesy goodness.  It is a longtime local favorite known for classic New York–style pizza, generous slices, and a no-frills neighborhood feel. It’s a go-to spot for consistently good pizza, late-night slices, and a laid-back, old-school vibe that locals have trusted for years.

      545 W 3900 S, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 996-3485

🌐 Webisite

10. Villaggio Pizzeria

Family-run, East-Coast-style pizza spot turning out giant, cheesy slices.

Order the Ferragosto with ricotta and pesto for a Utah-meets-Brooklyn bite.

If you,re looking for authentic new york style pizza this is the place.  The crust is the secret.  Thin, crunchy goodness.  Try Villaggio's pizza.  

      3144 S State St, Ste 1, South Salt Lake

📞 (801) 410-4355

🌐 Website

11. MOZZ Artisan Pizza

Stylish, modern pizzeria using naturally fermented dough and premium ingredients.  Expect perfectly charred crusts and smart flavor combinations.

Mozz delivers a great pizza.  Try their salads you won't be disappointed.

      700 S 545 W, Suite 104, Salt Lake City

📞 (385) 205-6316

🌐 Website

12. Este Pizzeria

Este Pizzeria is a Utah favorite serving authentic New York–style pizza, salads, and garlic knots, with locations in Salt Lake City and Park City, plus vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options.

Awesome tasting pizza with Utah heart. Foldable, oversized slices and plenty of attitude.  

     156 E 200 S, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 363-2366

🌐 Website

13. Free Wheeler Pizza

Since 1977, Free Wheeler Pizza has served hand-tossed specialty pies in Salt Lake City, made with a decades-old sourdough starter and a signature blend of cheeses and seasonings.

A downtown classic since the '80s.  Known for its awesome crust, loaded pies, and late-night hours—a go-to after concerts or bar-hopping.  

      150 S 400 E, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 322-3733

🌐 Website

14. Rusted Sun Pizzeria

Neighborhood comfort food at its best.  Consistent, affordable, and always friendly—a real "locals' pizza joint."

Thin-crust pizzas featuring pesto, artichokes, and other gourmet toppings, complemented by calzones and a selection of fresh salads.

       2010 S State St, Salt Lake City

 📞 (801) 483-2120

🌐  Website

15. Pizzeria Limone

Pizza Limone is a Utah-based restaurant chain specializing in Neapolitan-revival style pizzas. Founded in 2011, the company has grown to nine locations across the Wasatch Front, serving fast, high-quality, hand-stretched personal pizzas.

Pizza Limone is fast and inexpensive but delivers on quality ingredients and taste.  The dough is surprisingly tasty.  The oven they use delivers a nice golden brown crust with a crunchy bite.  With nine locations it is best to go to the website and find a location nearest to you.

      613 E 400 S, Salt Lake City

📞 (801) 953-0200

🌐 Website

SLC Pizza Goes National: Watch Cosmica (our #1 pick) featured by The New York Times as one of the best restaurants in America.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Is "Secret Pizza Club" actually a real thing?

Yes, but you have to work for it. Secret Pizza Club (run by Sam Pew and often listed as Sam Makes Pizza) is a weekly pop-up at Leavity Bread & Coffee. It became a legend after Dave Portnoy gave it an 8.2 score in late 2025.

💠How to order: Pre-order spots typically open every Tuesday morning for the following week via their Hotplate link found in the @sammakespizza Instagram bio. 

💠The other secret: Baby’s Bagels (700 S. Main St) also runs "After Hours" pizza nights. You have to watch the @babysbagels Instagram stories for "drop" announcements, as they usually require a similar pre-order through a link in their bio and sell out in minutes.

Q. What was the Dave Portnoy "One Bite" controversy in Salt Lake?

Portnoy’s visit in late 2025 shook up the scene. He loved Villaggio (7.8), calling it a "great New York slice," but his 6.9 score for The Pie Pizzeria caused an uproar. Fans argued that he reviewed their thin crust—which most locals don't even order—instead of the massive, cheese-heavy "Combo" they are famous for.

Q. Is Detroit-style pizza actually a thing in Salt Lake now?

It’s huge for 2026. Brick’s Corner is the local king of the "frico" (cheese-crust) edge, but Via 313 has also brought authentic Austin-style Detroit squares to Murray, Sandy, and Riverton. It’s the go-to style if you want something thick, square, and crispy. Very tasty!

Q. Where can I get a single slice instead of a whole pizza?

For a quick lunch or a late-night craving, Pie Hole downtown is the classic choice for a thin, "no-frills" slice. If you want a more gourmet individual slice, Slice House (from world champion Tony Gemignani) recently opened on Foothill Drive and offers high-quality New York and Sicilian slices by the piece.  Also try Villaggio Pizza for a huge New York style slice.

Q. Are there good gluten-free or vegan pizza options in Salt Lake City?

Salt Lake is very dietary-friendly. Settebello and Pizzeria Limone have the most reliable gluten-free crusts that hold up to the heat of the oven. For vegan eaters, Slackwater offers the most creative plant-based toppings that actually taste like a real meal rather than an afterthought.

Summary:

From red-brick ovens to innovative newcomers, these fifteen pizzerias showcase the rich and diverse pizza culture thriving in Salt Lake City.

Next time you're craving a slice, explore these local favorites and experience some of the best the city has to offer.